Here on The Fandomentals, we try to provide commentary not only about popular pieces of media, but also on fandom tendencies, as participating in fandoms is at times, a most mysterious endeavor. After thinking about the concept of shipping wars, I got to thinking about another particular habit of Highly Effective Fangirls (trademark pending). Those who are familiar with the concept of “stanning” for a character, or when the celebration goes too far, may see the fandom trope “Draco in Leather Pants” in action.
This is when members of a fandom take a character who is, by all accounts, not very nice (and normally an antagonist), and downplays their flaws, painting them as a victim and/or object of desire. Draco Malfoy is a lil’ shit, but stick him in some hot pants and suddenly he’s adorbs. We tend to see this manifest in fanfic and fanart. Not that I don’t love fanart of Draco making cupcakes with Hermione, just to be clear.
And of course, given how art and fics are the lifeblood of fandoms once a piece of media concludes, we definitely see the leather pants handprint (butt-print?) in fandom conversations.
Now, this is something that I kind of *knew* happened, but until I began actively participating in the Legend of Korra (LoK) during its final two seasons, I never really saw. But boy was my first experience with it surprising: the character ‘Kuvira’, a dictator who in the Book 4 opener was already strong-arming regional leaders to cave into her demands and putting others in life-threatening situations unless they pledged loyalty to her.
As I got further into this fandom, I soon discovered that another character from LoK’s predecessor, Avatar: The Last Airbender (AtLA) was also frequently leather pantsed. And this was none-other than Azula, Zuko’s sister who served, in my opinion, as the primary antagonist for the series versus her father, who had more of an Emperor Palpatine presence.
Now, the point of this article is not at all to shame anybody for stanning either of these characters, nor for rationalizing away some of their more unsavory behavior. There was actually a time where Azula was dangerously close to becoming leather pantsed in my analyses when I was attempting to figure out why she was also the target of incredibly misogynistic attack posts on the other side, until I received a moving, thoughtful piece that helped re-center my lens. I do know all about that razor’s edge between understanding motivations and excusing actions better than I like to admit.
So no, instead what I’d like to do is describe Azula and Kuvira’s attributes and let you decide who wore their leather pants better?
Let’s start with Azula, because…chronology?
Azula is a challenging antagonist because there is…justification for why she acts as she does. Is “justification” the right word?
Like her brother Zuko, she was raised in an abusive household. Sadly, though perhaps painfully realistically, she was turned into a secondary abuser at the hands of her father. However, there’s a true tragedy to her character as well. We are shown her inability to socialize with others her age, and it’s something that seems to upset her on some level, or at least enough for her to ask Ty Lee’s advice on how to flirt. This is directly connected to her guiding mantra that “fear is safer than love,” which is simply horrifying when you consider that this is a fourteen year-old who internalized it so heavily that she is ready to violently fight one of her best friends if they don’t behave how she demands.
By all accounts, Azula is a child-soldier, groomed and hardened in a chilling way. Then she begins to “slip” during the last season; we see her becoming increasingly paranoid after Mai’s betrayal, and she also exhibits certain signs of psychosis (like imagining her mother appearing in her mirror). I’m not a fan of diagnosing fictional characters, but it is made abundantly clear that she is not well.
When Zuko and Azula finally face each other in the finale, there’s no “take-down” in the traditional sense. The mood instead is very “how did it come to this?”
So, given that tragedy, the leather pantsing is quite understandable. And yet…we have to get to her actions.
Officially, Azula was tasked with the job of locating her brother and bringing him back to the Fire Nation (as a prisoner). Here’s what she did:
- Threatened her friend Ty Lee’s life by sabotaging her circus act (having the circus master light the safety net on fire and releasing every animal onto the stage while Ty Lee was balancing on the high wire) until her friend agreed to join her group.
- Refused to exchange hostages to get Mai’s baby brother back (she kinda had a point there, tbh).
- Showed no hesitation in her (sometimes multiple) attempts to kill: Zuko, her uncle Iroh, Aang, Sokka, Katara, etc., and was very nearly successful with her brother, her uncle, and Aang.
- Infiltrated the Earth Kingdom’s capital city, obtained military information, took control of the city’s police (for lack of a better term) by striking a deal with their leader only to betray him after gaining the loyalty of his entire force, which she cited as being the result of her “divine right to rule,” and then toppled Ba Sing Se by executing a coup where the Earth Kingdom’s king and generals were captured.
- When Zuko chose to rejoin the Fire Nation, lied to their father and gave him the credit for “killing” the Avatar because she suspected Aang might have survived her shot, which gave her leverage over her brother and protected herself from any negative consequences.
- Suggested in a war meeting that her father harness the power of an approaching comet to burn the entirety of the Earth Kingdom “to ashes,” a plan which Ozai decided to adopt.
What a sweetie!
But don’t worry, we have another grand contender in the form of Kuvira.
I called Azula a “challenging” antagonist, but that’s not to say that Kuvira is a literary breeze. She’s actually a great character, designed to be an almost perfect foil for Korra. And while her background is not quite as tragic as the princess’s, it’s not to say it was all smooth sailing for Kuvira either.
She was an orphan, “taken in” by Suyin Beifong, at least in a mentor/mentee capacity. This is complicated, because while Suyin claims that Kuvira was “like a daughter” to her, she also talks about “nourishing her talents” and seeing her “rise through the ranks,” which is not the most maternal thing in the world, to say the least. Also Suyin’s not the most objective person in the world. I guess what I’m trying to say is that Kuvira’s orphan-status was something that stayed with her, to the point where Korra cited it as one of the guiding reasons for her behavior, though to be perfectly honest, this always made more sense to me for Korra’s character than for Kuvira’s, since Book 4 spent the entire time developing the relationship between Kuvira and Suyin and framing that as Kuvira’s motivation for her actions in Zaofu.
Where Azula was a soldier for the Fire Nation who was trying to take over the entire world because they believed themselves superior, Kuvira was a military figure in the Earth Kingdom during a time when it was descending into political chaos as the result of the Earth Queen’s assassination. She was tasked with uniting and bringing stability to the Earth Kingdom once again, which had fallen into a more tribal (or state-focused) mentality to deal with the mass amounts of bandits. I’m not saying her means get a free pass, but having a safe and politically unified Earth Kingdom is a better end than scorching an enemy’s nation to the ground to win a war of conquest, no?
But…time to discuss Kuvira’s pesky ol’ actions:
- Established a chain of “reeducation” camps (aka labor camps) for dissenters in her unified states (and no I won’t hear that this wasn’t confirmed; they didn’t script Baatar Jr. to say the words “hard truths, Bolin” just for kicks).
- Established mandatory conscription for all states under her protection and withdrew their resources regardless of the condition this would leave the area in (she may have a point here when the choice is this or bandits, though it should be noted that all loyalty was pledged to her specifically, not the Earth Kingdom).
- Gave bandits the “option” of joining her by tying them to railroad tracks and refusing to free them otherwise.
- Refused to step down from her post after the coronation of Prince Wu (I guess “King Wu,” but literally no one recognized this ever), instead declaring herself the Emperor of the Earth Kingdom and telling the world leaders who appointed her that if they tried to interfere with “internal Earth Kingdom” matters then they would be crushed.
- Suspended a scientist outside of a moving train car by a metal collar, choking him and threatening to drop him when he said that he had no desire to develop a super weapon out of a project that he thought was going to be about finding a source of clean energy.
- Marched an army to the city of Zaofu (Suyin’s city, shockingly) and then manipulated the situation to where she could pretend they were the aggressors leaving her “no choice” but to take the city and imprison every Beifong.
- Just prior to that threatened to chuck Bolin into one of her reeducation camps when he suggested that they don’t capture city.
- Kept the Beifongs in a suspended cage for an unspecified period of time.
- Developed the “super weapon,” which she then installed onto a giant walking robot that she marched, along with her army, to capture Republic City because it was on land that had belonged to the Earth Kingdom 70 years ago.
- Almost blew up her fiancé because that also meant she would have successfully murdered the Avatar, the leader of the Air Nation, and Suyin.
- Basically destroyed the entirety of Republic City before Korra gave her a talking to in the Spirit World, even though its president already told her he’d surrender.
So there you have it! Two perfect cinnamon rolls. Who do you think is more worthy of those leather pants?
Images courtesy of Nickelodeon